AI Robotics

Robots in Construction

Robots in construction enhance efficiency and safety, addressing labor shortages and sustainable building practices.
Robots in Construction

Introduction 

The advent of robots in construction is catalyzing a significant shift in an industry typically steeped in manual labor and conventional methods. Construction robots, with their diverse shapes and sizes, are making a significant impact, from autonomous vehicles performing detailed site surveys to robotic arms proficient in executing tasks such as bricklaying, concrete pouring, or drywall installation with superhuman precision.

Underlying these innovations are cutting-edge technologies like Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning, and advanced sensor systems. Incorporating robots in construction isn’t just about enhancing productivity and efficiency—it’s also about fundamentally improving safety by minimizing hazardous tasks. The surge of robots in construction marks the beginning of an exciting era where human creativity and robotic efficiency collaborate to establish safer, faster, and more environmentally friendly construction processes.

Welcome to the Future: The Dawn of Robotic Construction

As construction companies around the globe grapple with the challenges of labor shortage and the inherent risks of dangerous tasks, the industry is witnessing a paradigm shift with the integration of construction robotics. These robots, ranging from mobile robots navigating construction sites to advanced industrial robots, serve as indispensable assets in modern construction.

Mobile robots, equipped with AI and sensor technologies, help in performing detailed site inspections, transporting heavy objects, and even assisting in intricate tasks that would typically require a human worker. The advent of these robots on construction sites is not only improving efficiency but also mitigating risks associated with dangerous tasks.

Advanced Construction Robotics, characterized by sophisticated, autonomous construction equipment, are increasingly being adopted for complex operations that require extreme precision. These include, but are not limited to, bricklaying, concrete pouring, or drywall installation. Industrial robots can work round the clock, unaffected by harsh weather conditions or fatigue, thereby reducing project timelines and augmenting productivity.

They alleviate the need for human workers to perform high-risk tasks, promoting safer workplaces. With each construction project, these advancements in robotics are revolutionizing traditional workflows, marking the dawn of a new era in the construction industry where automation and human ingenuity collaborate to redefine what’s possible.

Also Read: This Robot-Built House Could Change Everything.

Building a New Era: The Rise of Robots in the Construction Industry

The future of robotics in the construction industry is rapidly taking shape, effectively setting the stage for a new era of innovation and productivity. The current demand for construction robots is escalating as these technologies prove their efficacy in reducing construction schedules and ensuring higher precision in construction tasks.

From heavy-duty operations to light construction tasks, robots are demonstrating an impressive versatility that’s starting to redefine the very core of construction processes. For instance, autonomous robotic equipment can work in harsh weather conditions, execute tasks round the clock, and maintain a level of consistency that surpasses human capacity, thereby significantly reducing project timelines and enhancing productivity.

There’s also a diverse range of types of construction robots currently available, each tailored to cater to specific needs of the industry. Semi-autonomous and fully autonomous mobile robots are adept at performing routine tasks, such as material handling and site inspections, while robotic arms can accurately execute bricklaying or concrete pouring tasks.

Even more complex tasks such as steel tying and scaffolding are now within the capabilities of advanced construction robots. As we witness the rising tide of robots in the construction industry, it is clear that they are not only instrumental in meeting present-day challenges but also in shaping the future of the construction landscape.

Also Read: Introduction to Robot Safety Standards

Types of Robots In Construction

Brick Laying Robots – SAM

Brick laying, a process traditionally carried out manually by skilled laborers, is witnessing a transformation with the introduction of specialized brick-laying robots in the construction industry. These innovative machines provide a blend of efficiency, speed, and accuracy that’s difficult to match with human labor alone. One notable example of a brick-laying robot is the SAM (Semi-Automated Mason) developed by Construction Robotics. SAM is designed to work in collaboration with a human mason, enhancing their productivity and reducing physical strain. It can lay about 3,000 bricks per day, nearly six times the average output of a human bricklayer, all while maintaining impeccable consistency and precision.

SAM uses a combination of advanced robotics, 3D CAD mapping, conveyer belts, and a robotic arm to pick up bricks, apply mortar, and lay them in the desired pattern. This technological innovation not only improves efficiency but also addresses the labor shortage problem, as fewer human bricklayers are required per project. The emergence of brick-laying robots like SAM signifies an exciting shift towards automated construction processes, paving the way for the future of the industry.

Source: YouTube

Hadrian X

Hadrian X, developed by Australian company Fastbrick Robotics (now known as FBR Ltd), represents a significant leap forward in the sphere of automated bricklaying technology. Unlike traditional construction methods, Hadrian X is an autonomous robot that uses a unique 3D robotic end-to-end system for the laying of bricks. Capable of working around the clock, it can lay approximately 1,000 bricks per hour, drastically exceeding the output of a human worker and greatly improving efficiency on construction sites.

The robotic arm of Hadrian X, with its 30-meter reach, can construct a residential house in a matter of days, precisely placing bricks after applying adhesive, according to a 3D model plan. Using advanced algorithms and machine learning, it adjusts for variables like wind, vibration, and other environmental factors in real-time to ensure pinpoint accuracy. This minimizes the errors that may arise during construction, leading to substantial cost savings and enhanced construction speed. Hadrian X, therefore, epitomizes the transformative potential of robotics in construction, heralding a new era of efficiency, speed, and precision in the industry.

Source: YouTube

Theometrics

Theometrics, a groundbreaking technology firm in the architectural, engineering, and construction industries, is paving the way for the robotic execution of construction layouts. Traditionally, construction layouts – the process of transferring architectural plans from blueprints to the physical building site – require substantial manual effort, experience, and time. However, the advent of Theometrics’ robotic system has dramatically revolutionized this process.

Theometrics’ robotic system leverages advanced algorithms and precise positioning technologies to automate the transfer of digital plans into real-world coordinates on the construction site. Equipped with the ability to navigate through complex structures, it eliminates human errors and significantly reduces the time taken to layout designs. The robot can mark critical points such as electrical outlets, HVAC ductwork, plumbing fixtures, and structural components, with extreme accuracy, thereby ensuring that every aspect of the construction aligns perfectly with the original design.

This automated process mitigates the risk of costly construction reworks and delays resulting from layout errors, leading to improved efficiency and cost-effectiveness. The introduction of Theometrics’ robot in construction layout processes is thus a major leap towards a future where robotics and digitization play a central role in construction, ensuring precision, speed, and reliability in every project.

Demolition Robots – Brokk Robots

The field of demolition, inherently risky and labor-intensive, is witnessing a transformation with the advent of demolition robots. These machines are designed to execute the teardown of structures in a controlled, precise, and safe manner. They are usually equipped with a variety of tools, including breakers, crushers, and buckets, which can be interchanged depending on the specific requirements of a task.

One notable example of a demolition robot is the Brokk series from the Swedish company of the same name. Brokk robots are remote-controlled demolition machines renowned for their compact design, power, and versatility. Despite their small size, they pack the power to carry out heavy-duty demolition tasks while ensuring safety. Thanks to their electric power source, they can operate without producing harmful exhaust gases, making them ideal for indoor demolition projects.

These robots can access tight spaces and hazardous areas that may be risky for human workers, reducing the potential for injuries or accidents. They also increase efficiency by being able to work continuously without fatigue. The introduction of demolition robots like the Brokk series underscores the potential of robotic technologies to revolutionize construction by enhancing safety and efficiency, particularly in tasks that have traditionally been considered dangerous for human workers.

Source: YouTube

Self-Driving Trucks & Heavy Equipment

The application of autonomous technology in the construction industry extends beyond robots and drones; self-driving trucks and heavy equipment are now becoming increasingly prevalent. These vehicles leverage advanced sensors, GPS systems, and artificial intelligence to navigate construction sites, perform tasks, and even transport materials, all without human intervention.

Volvo Autonomous Hauler

A standout example of self-driving trucks is the Volvo Autonomous Hauler. Designed specifically for mining operations, these trucks can transport heavy loads of materials across challenging terrains with improved safety and efficiency. They use precise GPS tracking and LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) systems to create a detailed map of their surroundings and follow pre-set routes, eliminating the risks associated with human error.

Source: YouTube

Komatsu’s Innovative Autonomous Haulage Vehicle (AHV)

Komatsu’s Innovative Autonomous Haulage Vehicle (AHV) is another example, a dump truck that doesn’t even have a driver’s cab. It’s designed to maximize its payload and improve its overall efficiency by eliminating the need for the driver to turn the vehicle.

Source: YouTube

Built Robotics

In terms of heavy equipment, Built Robotics is retrofitting off-the-shelf heavy equipment to build autonomous bulldozers, excavators, and compact track loaders. These machines use AI guidance systems to perform tasks such as digging and grading, which can help to increase productivity on construction sites, especially during labor shortages or in remote or hazardous environments.

The rise of self-driving trucks and heavy equipment in the construction industry is signaling a future where autonomous technology will play an even greater role, promising improved safety, efficiency, and productivity in construction logistics.

Jobsite Monitoring

In the contemporary construction industry, jobsite monitoring plays a pivotal role, with a heightened emphasis on safety, efficiency, and productivity. To ensure comprehensive and precise jobsite monitoring, a variety of advanced technologies such as AI, IoT (Internet of Things), drones, and robotic systems are being deployed.

DJI Drones

Drones, such as those produced by DJI, stand as a prime example of this integration. Equipped with high-resolution cameras and various sensors, these drones conduct regular flyovers of construction sites. They capture detailed aerial imagery and video footage in real time, offering a comprehensive perspective of the site. This data can then be analyzed for progress tracking, safety hazard identification, stockpile volume measurements, and even the creation of 3D site models for deeper analysis.

Source: YouTube

SPOT Robot

In the sphere of robotic systems, Boston Dynamics’ Spot stands out as an innovative tool for jobsite monitoring. This quadruped robot is capable of navigating through complex terrains and capturing high-quality images and videos, which can be used for inspecting hard-to-reach areas and detecting safety risks. Its autonomous nature allows for routine site inspections, ensuring that potential issues are caught early.

Source: YouTube

Triax’s Spot-r

On the other hand, wearable technology has also made a significant impact on jobsite monitoring. Triax’s Spot-r, a wearable device, tracks workers’ locations within a jobsite, monitors their activity, and even detects falls or other incidents in real time. This type of technology not only enhances safety but also aids in resource allocation and productivity tracking.

Source: YouTube

These technological advancements in jobsite monitoring are bolstering construction companies’ capabilities, facilitating real-time decision making, enhancing safety, and leading to more efficient and successful construction projects.

Rebar Work

Rebar work, an essential yet laborious and time-consuming task in the construction process, is experiencing a wave of transformation with the introduction of robotic technology. These robots are designed to automate the process of tying steel reinforcement bars (rebar), enhancing efficiency, precision, and safety on construction sites.

TyBot

A prime example of such an innovation is the robotic system developed by Advanced Construction Robotics, known as TyBot. TyBot is an autonomous rebar-tying robot designed to work uninterrupted across a large deck, identifying intersections of rebar and securely tying them. This robot uses machine vision to locate the intersections, and an arm to tie the rebar securely, ensuring the structural integrity of the construction project.

With the ability to work in a wide range of environmental conditions and around the clock, TyBot can dramatically increase productivity by completing rebar work significantly faster than a human crew, while also reducing the risk of repetitive strain injuries. By handling a process that is often considered monotonous and physically demanding, TyBot allows human workers to focus on tasks that require complex decision-making and craftsmanship. Thus, the advent of rebar work robots like TyBot signifies an important step toward optimizing construction processes through automation.

Source: YouTube

Additive manufacturing – 3D Printed Homes

Additive manufacturing, particularly in the form of 3D printed homes, is making a measurable impact in the construction industry. Through the use of 3D materials such as concrete and plastic composites, an assortment of machines can efficiently construct entire structures layer by layer based on digital models. These 3D printed homes are not only cost-efficient but also reduce construction time significantly. The precision of 3D printing minimizes material waste, contributing to sustainability efforts within the industry.

The flexibility and adaptability of additive manufacturing also allows for the creation of additional features that would be difficult, if not impossible, with traditional construction methods. Complex architectural designs, unique geometrical structures, and even the capability to 3D-print an underground structure are now possible. With the advancements in materials and technology, 3D printed homes can now include intricate design elements, superior insulation properties, and increased resilience to environmental factors. The implementation of 3D printing in home construction is set to continue its upward trajectory, offering a promising solution to efficient, sustainable, and innovative housing needs.

Source: YouTube

Transforming Traditions: How Robots Are Revolutionizing the Construction Site

The integration of robotics into the construction industry is altering traditional workflows and practices, bringing forth a revolution that promises enhanced efficiency, safety, and productivity. This transformation, although gradual, has been significant, influencing every aspect of a construction project – from design and planning to execution and monitoring. Robots, with their advanced capabilities, are tackling various challenges that have long hindered the industry, including labor shortages, safety concerns, and the need for precision and speed.

Construction robots, ranging from autonomous bulldozers to brick-laying machines, are performing tasks traditionally executed by human workers, but at a higher speed and with increased precision. For instance, robots like the Semi-Automated Mason (SAM) can lay bricks with remarkable consistency and at a rate nearly six times faster than a human bricklayer. Autonomous equipment like Komatsu’s Innovative Autonomous Haulage Vehicle (AHV) and Volvo’s Autonomous Hauler are altering the dynamics of heavy-duty tasks, minimizing human risk and optimizing performance. Even in the sphere of rebar tying and demolition, robots like TyBot and Brokk are making significant strides, making these labor-intensive tasks more efficient and less hazardous.

The role of robots is not confined to physical labor. They are making considerable impacts in the areas of jobsite monitoring and layout planning as well. Robotic systems like Boston Dynamics’ Spot and drones from companies like DJI are playing crucial roles in site inspections, progress tracking, and hazard detection. Meanwhile, technologies like Theometrics are automating construction layouts, ensuring extreme accuracy and saving considerable time.

The revolution brought by robots is not just transforming traditional practices, but it is also shaping the future of the construction industry. With continuous advancements in robotic technologies, we can anticipate an era of construction where manual labor is significantly reduced, safety is paramount, and efficiency is the norm. This transformation signifies a leap towards an industry driven by innovation, automation, and smart technologies.

Safety First: Robots Minimize Risk in Construction Work

Ensuring safety on construction sites is a top priority, and with the advent of robotic technology, the industry is witnessing a significant reduction in workplace risks. Robots, with their precision and tirelessness, are taking over tasks that are inherently dangerous or physically demanding for human workers. By assigning such tasks to robots, the risks of accidents, injuries, and long-term health issues related to repetitive strain or overexertion are mitigated, enhancing overall site safety.

Robots like the demolition series from Brokk and remote-controlled excavation equipment from companies like Built Robotics are designed to work in hazardous environments and perform high-risk tasks. Their ability to operate in confined spaces, unstable structures, or areas with hazardous materials reduces the need for human intervention in such risky situations. Similarly, robotic systems like Boston Dynamics’ Spot can safely navigate difficult terrains and inspect hard-to-reach areas, providing critical data without putting human workers at risk.

Automated machines like Hadrian X and TyBot are also minimizing safety risks while enhancing productivity. Hadrian X, an autonomous bricklaying robot, can work at a rapid pace without the risk of fatigue-related errors or accidents. TyBot can tirelessly perform the physically demanding task of rebar tying, thus reducing the risk of repetitive strain injuries among workers.

Wearable tech and AI-powered safety systems are being used to monitor worker health and safety in real time. Devices like Triax’s Spot-r can detect falls, monitor heart rates, and even alert supervisors if a worker enters a potentially dangerous area.

Robotic technology is not just transforming construction work but is also setting new standards for workplace safety. By automating hazardous tasks and monitoring safety in real time, robots are playing an integral role in creating safer, more efficient construction sites. As technology advances, we can expect further enhancements in safety measures, making the construction industry safer and more resilient.

Construction Robots: A Solution to the Labor Shortage Crisis

The construction industry has been grappling with a significant labor shortage, posing a challenge to its growth and sustainability. In response to this pressing issue, the advent of construction robots is offering a promising solution. These robots are filling the labor gap by automating tasks traditionally done by humans, working with speed, precision, and the capability to operate continuously without fatigue.

Whether it’s SAM (Semi-Automated Mason) and Hadrian X performing brick-laying duties, TyBot executing rebar tying, or self-driving heavy equipment and trucks such as those retrofitted by Built Robotics and developed by Volvo and Komatsu, these innovations are mitigating the demand for skilled operators. In this way, robotic technology is not only revolutionizing the construction industry but also providing a viable solution to the ongoing labor shortage crisis.

Efficiency and Precision: The Unmatched Benefits of Robots in Construction

Robots are transforming the construction industry by offering unmatched benefits in terms of efficiency and precision. Their ability to operate continuously without fatigue allows them to complete tasks faster, increasing productivity on construction sites. Robots, such as Hadrian X for bricklaying or TyBot for rebar tying, perform their tasks with exceptional accuracy, reducing the risk of errors that could lead to costly rework or delays.

Even in tasks like site inspection and monitoring, robots and drones capture precise data, providing insights that enhance decision-making and planning. In an industry where time and precision directly influence profitability, the integration of robots is proving to be a game-changer, bringing a new level of efficiency and precision to construction projects.

The Environmental Edge: How Robots are Making Construction Greener

Robots are contributing to the greening of the construction industry in significant ways. With their precision and efficiency, they minimize waste by optimizing material usage and reducing the likelihood of errors that could result in resource wastage. Autonomous machinery, such as self-driving trucks and equipment, operate on electric or hybrid power systems, thereby cutting down on greenhouse gas emissions associated with traditional diesel-powered equipment.

Robots in construction often streamline processes and reduce the duration of projects, which in turn leads to less energy consumption over the construction phase. Through these ways, robots are not just improving the efficiency and safety of construction work but are also playing a critical role in reducing its environmental footprint and having a much better environmental impact. This will pave way for clean energy future by reducing pollution caused by construction in urban environments. 

Building Sky-high: Drones and Robots Reshaping Construction Landscapes

The incorporation of drones in the construction sector is significantly reshaping the industry, introducing new dimensions of efficiency, safety, and accuracy. Drones, equipped with high-resolution cameras and advanced sensors, are providing comprehensive aerial perspectives of construction sites. These unmanned aerial vehicles are being employed for a wide array of tasks, from topographical surveys and 3D mapping to real-time monitoring and inspection of structures.

Drones are particularly beneficial in large-scale or complex projects where manual inspections would be time-consuming, dangerous, or even impossible. They allow for more frequent and comprehensive inspections, ensuring that construction is proceeding as planned and helping to identify potential issues early. By capturing high-quality imagery and data, drones facilitate improved planning, accurate progress tracking, and proactive hazard detection, thereby enhancing overall project management. The transformation brought about by drones is allowing the construction industry to reach new heights, both literally and figuratively, in efficiency and safety.

AI and Robotics: The Dynamic Duo Streamlining Construction Processes

Artificial Intelligence (AI) and robotics have emerged as a dynamic duo in the construction industry, streamlining processes, enhancing efficiency, and reducing environmental impact. The integration of artificial intelligence software within advanced machines has led to the development of robots that can learn, adapt, and execute tasks with a degree of precision and speed unattainable by human workers. AI algorithms empower these robots to analyze data, make decisions, and carry out complex tasks autonomously. From heavy machinery equipped with AI units that allow for precision excavation and grading, to autonomous drones using AI for site inspections and mapping, this combination of AI and robotics is revolutionizing construction processes.

The intersection of AI and robotics is also unlocking new possibilities in additive manufacturing, more commonly known as 3D printing, in the construction industry. This technology is capable of constructing complex structures based on a 3-D model, with robots executing the build layer by layer with extraordinary accuracy. A prominent example includes the creation of adjustable walls and intricate architectural designs that were previously challenging and time-consuming to construct. This not only accelerates the construction process but also minimizes waste, helping reduce the environmental impact of building activities. As AI continues to evolve, and its integration with robotics becomes more refined, we can anticipate even greater advancements in the automation and efficiency of construction processes.

24/7 Construction: The Unstoppable Nature of Robotic Workers

The construction industry is witnessing a paradigm shift with the introduction of robotic workers capable of operating around the clock. Unlike their human counterparts, these autonomous systems don’t require breaks, thus accelerating the pace of any building project. Robotic platforms such as SAM (Semi-Automated Mason) and MULE (Material Unit Lift Enhancer) developed by Advanced Construction Robotics, Inc., are examples of autonomous construction robots designed to assist skilled workers by automating repetitive tasks and handling heavy materials. This constant productivity is helping project managers stay on or ahead of schedule, significantly improving the efficiency and profitability of construction projects.

Collaborative robots, or cobots, equipped with advanced technologies such as 3D vision, are transforming worksites into adaptable architectures, providing solutions to the labor crisis in the construction industry. These robots can operate alongside human workers, augmenting their capabilities and compensating for the scarcity of skilled labor. Cobots can perform tasks with high precision and consistency, and their deployment can address labor shortages by taking over strenuous and monotonous tasks, allowing human workers to focus on more complex and strategic aspects of a project. As the industry continues to innovate, the era of 24/7 construction through robotic workers is becoming a reality, setting new standards for productivity, safety, and efficiency.

Breaking Barriers: How Robotic Construction Can Aid in Disaster Relief

Robotic construction is breaking barriers and introducing innovative ways to aid in disaster relief. In the aftermath of natural disasters, construction robots can play a crucial role in rebuilding communities, providing faster and efficient construction solutions. Autonomous machines, capable of working around the clock, can expedite the rebuilding process, restoring essential structures like homes, schools, and hospitals much quicker than traditional methods. The utilization of such technology not only accelerates recovery but also significantly reduces risk by limiting human exposure to potentially unsafe environments.

The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) with construction robots can provide critical advancements in disaster relief efforts. AI for route optimization can guide machines through disaster-stricken areas more efficiently, and vulnerability mapping can help identify structures most in need of repair. This allows for better prioritization of resources, ensuring that the most critical needs are addressed promptly. The ability to quickly build back-ups of essential infrastructure could be a game-changer in disaster relief. With their inherent advantages of speed, efficiency, and safety, robots are poised to play a pivotal role in transforming how we respond to and recover from disasters, showcasing the immense potential of robotic construction in enhancing disaster relief efforts.

Embracing the Future: Preparing for the Inevitable Integration of Robots in Construction

The future of construction is here, and it is intertwined with the inevitable integration of robots. As collaborative robots, or CoBots, increasingly enter the construction industry, they are creating shared workspaces with humans, leading to a unique blend of human ingenuity and robotic precision. The use of AI algorithms enables intelligent distribution of tasks between humans and robots, ensuring workspace alignment and seamless collaboration. Humanoid robots can replicate human movements, enabling them to perform a variety of construction tasks traditionally reserved for skilled workers. This shift isn’t necessarily a threat to construction careers, but rather presents an opportunity for workers to learn new skills, embracing methods of construction that utilize advanced technology.

The applications of robots extend beyond the typical construction site, with space construction being a prime example of how advances in construction technology can reach new frontiers. Robots, with their ability to work in extreme environments, are being considered for constructing habitats on extraterrestrial bodies, where human exposure would be risky or impossible. On Earth, the adoption of technology, from AI-powered robots to additive manufacturing techniques, is already reshaping aspects of construction work, promoting safety, precision, and efficiency. As the industry continues to embrace these advancements, it is crucial for stakeholders to invest in up-skilling the workforce, encouraging technological literacy, and fostering an environment of innovation to fully realize the potential of robots in construction.

Also Read: How Construction Robots Will Shake up the Industry

Conclusion

The advent of robotics in construction has indisputably revolutionized the industry, enhancing efficiency, safety, and precision. From semi-automated masons to self-driving heavy equipment and drones for surveying and monitoring, the applications of robotics have introduced a level of automation and accuracy previously unimagined. As we continue to explore the vast potential of robotics, it is clear that this technology is not merely an auxiliary tool but an integral part of the future of construction. With the right training and approach, the human workforce can work hand-in-hand with these advancements, optimizing the construction process and overcoming challenges in the industry. As we embrace this era of robotic construction, we are shaping a future where robots and humans coexist and collaborate, leveraging their unique strengths to build better, safer, and more sustainable structures.

Augment It: How Architecture, Engineering and Construction Leaders Leverage Data and Artificial Intelligence to Build a Sustainable Future
$9.99
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
10/28/2024 05:33 pm GMT

References

Balaguer, Carlos, and Mohamed Abderrahim. Robotics and Automation in Construction. BoD – Books on Demand, 2008.

Cousineau, Leslie, and Nobuyasu Miura. Construction Robots: The Search for New Building Technology in Japan. ASCE Publications, 1998.

Jebelli, Houtan, et al. Automation and Robotics in the Architecture, Engineering, and Construction Industry. Springer Nature, 2022.

Lee, Seungyeol. Glazed Panel Construction with Human-Robot Cooperation. Springer Science & Business Media, 2011.